Soft-Shell Crabs With Curry Butter Recipe (2024)

Ratings

5

out of 5

119

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

John Duncan

Great! Don't forget to deglaze the pan with ½ cup of the Riesling you're serving with dinner. Drizzle it across the crabs before serving. Never let that "shrapnel" in the pan go to waste!

Catherine DiNardo

Made the curry butter according to the recipe except added the spices, garlic, ginger, scallions, lime zest and juice to 1 stick of butter instead of 2. The flavor was amazing! To cook the crabs, used the technique from Melissa Clark's Soft Shell Crab Toast recipe, lightly brushing the crabs with the curry butter. Served on top of lightly wilted fresh spinach with extra curry butter spooned on top as this recipe instructs. Excellent dish! Will make again for guests.

Stephen

This is delicious, but you can definitely make do with just one stick of butter unless you're cooking for a crowd. Even if you do the step with the pea shoots or spinach (and do you really want, along with the crabs, to cook your veggies in half a stick of butter?), you'll have some of the curry butter left over. It would be great for sauteed shrimp or scallops.

Mary Ellen

Made this for supper tonight. Didn't have all the ingredients to make the curry according to the recipe, so I adjusted with ground spices and red curry powder, sweet onion. Lime zest and juice is a great ingredient. A big hit with my family. Great recipe for soft shells. Encouraged my family to use up the left-over curry butter with their eggs. Thank you, David.

dk

I'm thinking about trying this out with shrimp instead of softies

Judith Williams

Awesome recipe! I halved the butter and added a tsp or so of chili oil and a splash of fish sauce. I skipped the nuts and used frozen peas instead of shoots. Super fab and delicious! I highly recommend!

skyandstars

This makes a wonderful compound butter! Use what you need for the recipe and shape the rest into a roll, wrap well, and freeze or chill. Cooks and chefs know that a compound butter is an "ace up the sleeve" to take an otherwise simple dish- sauteed fish, chicken breasts, steak, onto another level.

ZGBNM

Excellent, excellent recipe. Licked the plate. Used all powdered spices. Dusted with all purpose flour. Came out perfect. I had collards (made Brazilian style per TCooking - ie quick sauté) and it was a delicious fast substitute. Crabs do pop, so have splatter screen at the ready. Perfect way to cook this seasonal treat.

Flo

Halved the recipe and followed it to a T. The high stovetop temp recommended singed the butter, resulting in it being somewhat burnt. Even with additional butter for pea shoots, pot did not have any leftover butter to drizzle on top of crab, so I put some of the unused butter directly on top of crab. That said, the crab and pea shoots made for an elegant plate and both were very good. Served w/2017 Domaine Serene Evensted Reserve Chardonnay.

Rachel Pierson

This is fabulous. Curry butter could be used with shrimp and other seafood as well. Family loved it.

Jordan Lourie

Made it. It really complemented the soft shell crabs. Spicy but not at all overwhelming.... will make it again.. terrific blend of flavors and spices!

Terry

Delicious! I didn’t change a thing.

Stephen

This is delicious, but you can definitely make do with just one stick of butter unless you're cooking for a crowd. Even if you do the step with the pea shoots or spinach (and do you really want, along with the crabs, to cook your veggies in half a stick of butter?), you'll have some of the curry butter left over. It would be great for sauteed shrimp or scallops.

Judith Williams

Awesome recipe! I halved the butter and added a tsp or so of chili oil and a splash of fish sauce. I skipped the nuts and used frozen peas instead of shoots. Super fab and delicious! I highly recommend!

John Duncan

Great! Don't forget to deglaze the pan with ½ cup of the Riesling you're serving with dinner. Drizzle it across the crabs before serving. Never let that "shrapnel" in the pan go to waste!

Catherine DiNardo

Made the curry butter according to the recipe except added the spices, garlic, ginger, scallions, lime zest and juice to 1 stick of butter instead of 2. The flavor was amazing! To cook the crabs, used the technique from Melissa Clark's Soft Shell Crab Toast recipe, lightly brushing the crabs with the curry butter. Served on top of lightly wilted fresh spinach with extra curry butter spooned on top as this recipe instructs. Excellent dish! Will make again for guests.

Melanie Loots

My husband cooked these on Thursday and they were fabulous with fingerling potatoes and spinach.

brcooks

Not a big curry fan....what about using Melissa's green garlic butter instead? Gotta try it.

dk

I'm thinking about trying this out with shrimp instead of softies

Mary Ellen

Made this for supper tonight. Didn't have all the ingredients to make the curry according to the recipe, so I adjusted with ground spices and red curry powder, sweet onion. Lime zest and juice is a great ingredient. A big hit with my family. Great recipe for soft shells. Encouraged my family to use up the left-over curry butter with their eggs. Thank you, David.

Michele Farley

Your recipes are always wonderful...simple but interesting and most of all delicious. Going to try this one in the next few days. Thanks.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Soft-Shell Crabs With Curry Butter Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What is the best way to prepare soft shell crab? ›

The best preparation for soft shell crabs is achieved by a simply soaking the crabs in seasoned buttermilk, dredging in flour and pan frying.

Should you soak soft shell crabs in milk? ›

A quick soak in milk gets the crabs ready for drenching. In order to cook these little monsters through and get the outside crispy, you need to almost flash-fry them.

What month is best for soft shell crabs? ›

When is soft shell crab season? We are in soft shell crab season along the Gulf Coast of Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and Florida. It usually starts in early April and runs through October or early November. The season runs longer than the Chesapeake or East Coast.

How long does it take for soft shell crab to harden? ›

They shed their outer shell, then take in water, causing the softened shell to expand and grow. Within a couple of hours after they shed, the new shell begins hardening. Once they reach “paper shell” stage — most experts say that is within about 12 hours — the shell is tougher.

Do you have to clean soft shell crabs before cooking? ›

Don't prep soft shells too far in advance, there will be a large amount of moisture loss. Clean them right before you intend to cook them. Soft shells can be kept alive for a few days under the right conditions. Don't keep them on ice, it'll kill them.

How long do soft shell crabs last in the refrigerator? ›

Soft Shell Crabs- Soft crabs can be kept in the refrigerator for 3-4 days. Any longer length of time they should be stored in the freezer.

Why are my boiled crabs mushy? ›

When a crab is not kept alive prior to cooking, its flesh degrades very quickly and becomes soft and mushy. Fresh crabs have firm and bouncy flesh that springs back when pressed. If any part of your crab's flesh has become mushy and semi-solid, this is an indication that it was not alive when cooked.

Why is soft shell crab so good? ›

Soft-shell crabs are famous in seafood restaurants because they have a wonderful flavor, are easy to eat, and are highly nutritious! Soft-shell crabs are any regular edible crabs, but in their natural, soft-shell condition—because they have just shed their old shells, in an event called molting.

How many soft shell crabs per person? ›

We recommend serving 2 Soft Shell Crabs per person.

Why are soft shell crabs so expensive? ›

A bevy of special peeler traps are required, which Richardson estimates cost $5,000 or $6,000 total. Add the attention to detail and the learning curve, and most crabbers don't bother with them. Now you know why you pay so much for a soft-shell crab sandwich at your favorite seafood joint.

Are frozen soft shell crabs good? ›

Softies freeze exceptionally well. They retain the texture and flavor of fresh soft shells, tasting almost as good as the day they were harvested.

How to tell if soft-shell crabs are bad? ›

It may look like a good catch, but you are likely to be disappointed with the amount and quality of crab meat it yields. Pinch test: Holding the crab in one hand (r), pinch the large section of one of the walking legs ft). If the shell gives, the crab is still in its soft-shell form and will not be good eating.

How long to soak soft-shell crabs in milk? ›

Place the milk in a shallow bowl large enough to hold the crabs in a single layer. Add the crabs and let them soak for 1 hour. Drain and discard the milk.

Can I overcook crab? ›

Because it's already cooked and just needs to be reheated, overcooking is a common mistake. This will make the crab tough, rubbery, and not as flavorful. Even though it's a pricey meal, king crab is easy to prepare. A simple reheat in a steamer basket is all it takes to produce delicious, flakey crab meat.

Do you just eat the whole soft-shell crab? ›

Luckily, there are a variety of ways to enjoy these crabs and you don't have to painstakingly pick through parts to enjoy them. In fact, the entire shell of a soft-shell crab is completely edible. You get the same buttery crab meat, but with a slight crunch in every bite.

Do you eat the gills in soft-shell crab? ›

The exceptions are the mouthparts, the gills and the abdominal cover, which are discarded ("cleaned").

Do you take the guts out of soft-shell crab? ›

Now you ask: what about the intestines? They remain intact and are cooked fully, so, they won't hurt you or taste bad. If this just completely grosses you out you can do the following. When you go to eat the crab, break it in half and remove the intestines.

Are soft-shell crabs healthy? ›

Here are a few: They are high in Omega-3 fatty acids, essential to maintaining heart health.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 6508

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.